EXCLUSIVE: Director's promise over Wirral care home standards

Graham Hodkinson Graham Hodkinson

THE DIRECTOR in charge of Wirral adult social services has promised readers his officers are “working hard” to ensure high standards are being achieved in the borough’s care homes.

Graham Hodkinson was responding to a Globe inquiry as another Wirral home came under fire following an inspection by the sector’s watchdog, the Care Quality Commission.

Mother Redcaps in Wallasey has become the fifth home this year to fail to meet required standards.

The CQC issued its management with a formal warning after finding the 51-bed home was still failing to comply with Government regulations covering the management of medicines.

But Redcaps is just the latest in a line of non-compliance.

In January, CQC inspectors found Kingsley House, New Brighton, had failed to meet seven Government quality standards.

In March, the commission inspected Seabank House, Wallasey, and found people who used the service may have been at risk from staff who were not appropriately trained or appraised.

In April, Victoria House, also in Wallasey, was found to have not safeguarded against the risk of abuse. The commission was also concerned about residents' welfare, management of medicines and how care was monitored.

And in June, an inspection of the Anchorage Nursing Home in Hoylake found clients’ medical records were not fully compliant.

Mr Hodkinson, director of adult social services, said: “We work very hard to ensure that standards of provision in residential care homes reflect the high standards that the people of Wirral rightly expect.

“Our quality assurance team works very closely with the CQC and providers to monitor provision and to ensure that where necessary standards are improved.

“The council has invested in its quality assurance team to ensure that people receive a good standard of care and that we can react quickly where there are concerns.

“We work with the homes on issues such as training, recruitment and care planning processes to help them improve. This has happened in the case of Mother Redcaps.

“It is important to remember that people choose the care home that they want to live in – we do not place people as such, but support them financially with their personal choices where appropriate.”

Mr Hodkinson took over at DASS following an independent review which catalogued historic failures in the department. The inquiry, published in January, was carried out after a series of issues first raised in the Globe by whistleblower Martin Morton.

The report by investigator Anna Klonowski detailed a list of "serious and long-running failures" including:

• People with learning disabilities overcharged for services.

• Employees were scared to speak out against management for fear of reprisal.

• Failure to tackle issues raised by employees.

• Poor contract management of external providers of care.

The Local Government Association has since stepped in and set up an improvement board with the council to measure progress in adult social care.

According to the town hall's own website, a recent peer review of its progress found “promising” results.

Mr Hodkinson added: “This independent look at the progress and direction of our improvement plans allows us to take a breath and make sure we are on the right track.

“We are pleased that although we know there is still work to be done, it acknowledges we have a good foundation for further improvement.”

Comments(14)

RL 1952 says...
4:17pm Fri 20 Jul 12

It is about time the manangement of Wirral DASS took off their rose coloured spectacles. They may like to think things are improving but the reality is that the same unhealthy cultures remain. Unbelievably poor complaints management remains, they fail to uncover poor practice substandard providers are supported by DASS and complainants belittled and victimised. Contract Monitoring is at best poor with it recently being revealed that contact monitoring officers had not received professional training. If the Director thinks they address concerns then maybe it is time for him to part company with DASS as clearly being promoted from within has meant he is merely part of the malignant culture that remains having not been addressed since the AKA report

statictom says...
7:05pm Fri 20 Jul 12

Can I suggest Mr Hodgkinson gets out of his office and actually visits the premises that the DASS are responsible for. He will find for himself how poor some of the buildings are, never mind the care that goes on in them. His officers have been found wanting on numerous occasions, hence the bad reports and reputation of his department. Adult Day Services are in chaos. The promised Personal Budgets have still yet to appear, with only some 41% of service users actually in receipt of a budget. This is a department that has been restructured more times than I care to remember and yet fails to deliver time and time again. It is the dedicated staff at some of our Day Centres who strive to provide a decent service and certainly not the managers of this department.

hugo2008 says...
8:04pm Fri 20 Jul 12

Graham Hodgkinson inherited a poisoned chalice and he knew this when he took the job on.

He is failing to root out the corrupt useless individuals within his department,until he does this Wirral Council will remain in the depths of a poorly managed department full of corruption and useless parasites.

Stand on your back legs man and clear out the rubbish ruthlessly and without delay, or join the predecessors from this tainted department. regardless of politics.

WirralAl says...
10:10pm Fri 20 Jul 12

Only WBC would be pleased with failure.

unbeleivable says...
10:42pm Fri 20 Jul 12

A message to Mr Hodgkinson, you really really need to get out there and inspect yourself and think if you would recommend some of these placements for your own family? also you need to look at some of your providers namely one of your so called charity ones who u have given a contract to, they are paid a vast amount of money from service users fiunding and they have not or do they conduct themselves or look after the service users needs.

unbeleivable says...
10:44pm Fri 20 Jul 12

Sorry last sentence shld say They are paid a vast amount of money from the service users funding and they have not nor do they conduct themselves or look after the service users needs.

RL 1952 says...
10:26am Sat 21 Jul 12

WirralAl wrote:
Only WBC would be pleased with failure.
They are continually.

CQC report 2010 highlights spectacular failures

AKA report highlights unbelieveable unprofessional culture

and still it carries on - none so blind as those who don't want to see!!!

montague1 says...
5:34pm Sat 21 Jul 12

Resign,Resign,Resign
! REVERSE THIS APPALLING DECISION BEFORE YOU GO,AND THEN GET OUT!.
The people of Wirral have taken MORE THAN ENOUGH FROM INDIVIDUALS LIKE YOU IN THIS AUTHORITY!.
YOU ALL TREAT WIRRAL AS THOUGH IT IS YOUR FIEFDOM AND WE ARE YOUR SERFS!
Well, we are NOT!!!.
JUST GET OUT!!!!!!.

montague1 says...
8:32pm Sat 21 Jul 12

The above blog was intended for the NHS OAF who, like countless others before AND current, are intent on sucking everything that is good about Wirral out, making this lovely Peninsula and the electorate a laughing stock for taking it!
However, the sentiments fully apply here and elsewhere in this Authority.
In the main, they are bufoons and vagabonds with not an ounce of integrity!

Positive thinker says...
6:39pm Mon 23 Jul 12

Dear Mr Hodkison,

Let's put the seniors in jail and the criminals in a nursing home.This way the seniors would have acces to showers,hobbies and walks.They'd recieve unlimited free prescriptions,dental and medical treatment,wheelchair
s ect,and would recieve money instead of paying it out.They would have constant CCTV
monitoring so they could be helped if they fell ect.

Bedding would be changed twice a week all clothing would be washed ironed and returned to them.A guard would check on them every 20 minutes and bring meals and snacks to there cells.

They would recieve family visits in suites built for that purpose they would have use of library gym counselling education,nice private secure rooms complete with exercise area and garden.

Each senior could have a PC,TV,radio,daily phone calls there would be a board of directors to hear there complaints and the guards would have a strict code of conduct to
be adhered to.

The criminals would get cold food,be left all alone and unsupervised.Light of at 8.oclock showers once a week.They would live in a tiny room and pay a fortune for it,with no hope of getting out.

JOB DONE

antisthenes says...
6:53pm Tue 24 Jul 12

A rather cycnical PR ploy to signal to the new boss that 'Hodgers' is on the case.

The fact that he can be so overjoyed at the bland outcome of a half baked peer review tells you everything you need to know.

He has no idea what excellence in care means and even less vision of what can be achieved with leadership, drive, passion and imagination.

Wirral's adult care ethos is almost Victorian in its standards and aspirations and manangerialist in outlook and culture.

There are many excellent, committed and caring staff in the service whose insight into how things could be improved is still completely overlooked by the wilfull arrogance of the top brass.

statictom says...
11:01am Wed 25 Jul 12

"Positive Thinker". One of the best posts I have read in a long time.
Witty, but so true in this day and age.
I am due to attend a meeting with Managers of Social Services regarding the future of Day Care.
I intend to read your article to all present, maybe, just maybe it might strike a cord with them.

unbeleivable says...
11:04pm Sun 29 Jul 12

The biggest problem is............who do u trust to speak to?

PaulCa says...
11:17pm Sun 29 Jul 12

Positive thinker wrote:
Dear Mr Hodkison,

Let's put the seniors in jail and the criminals in a nursing home.This way the seniors would have acces to showers,hobbies and walks.They'd recieve unlimited free prescriptions,dental and medical treatment,wheelchair

s ect,and would recieve money instead of paying it out.They would have constant CCTV
monitoring so they could be helped if they fell ect.

Bedding would be changed twice a week all clothing would be washed ironed and returned to them.A guard would check on them every 20 minutes and bring meals and snacks to there cells.

They would recieve family visits in suites built for that purpose they would have use of library gym counselling education,nice private secure rooms complete with exercise area and garden.

Each senior could have a PC,TV,radio,daily phone calls there would be a board of directors to hear there complaints and the guards would have a strict code of conduct to
be adhered to.

The criminals would get cold food,be left all alone and unsupervised.Light of at 8.oclock showers once a week.They would live in a tiny room and pay a fortune for it,with no hope of getting out.

JOB DONE
"Positive Thinker" (know him from old) re-jigged / cut and pasted a common theme that's now been posted on every tedious half-baked forum in the land. Nothing original there.

Statictom, please don't embarrass yourself in front of those managers regurgitating this hackneyed drivel.

Try Googling it now, and there it is hundreds of examples of it on reams of pages, copied and pasted by people, one after the other, not capable of original thought.

Cheers!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree