LIBRARIES AXED (From Wirral Globe)
Send us news by text, start your message Globe News and your send photos and videos to 80360
LIBRARIES AXED
10:00am Wednesday 26th November 2008 in News By Justin Dunn
FINAL CHAPTER: Birkenhead’s historic Central Library will be closed and could even face being demolished
FOURTEEN libraries, three leisure centres and the Pacific Road arts venue are to be closed in a massive cost-cutting exercise proposed by Wirral Council.
A further twenty council properties including the former Birkenhead town hall in Hamilton Square, Leasowe Recreation Centre and a string of council-funded community centres and village halls across the borough also face being transferred to “community management” - where staff and funding are withdrawn to be replaced with volunteers and fundraisers.
The council admits that the drastic changes “will have significant implications for staff affected”, and that many of the buildings - like Birkenhead Library - face being mothballed or demolished.
Council leader Steve Foulkes said: “Doing nothing was never an option. If we leave things as they are we will be left with crumbling buildings, mounting repair costs and escalating levels of council tax.”
The borough hopes to make money from selling off “prime waterfront” sites like the one currently home to Guinea Gap Recreation Centre in Seacombe, which is included in the closures.
The moves are all part of the council’s wide-ranging review of its assets.
It is aiming to make savings by re-examining the number of buildings under its control, many of which were inherited when the council was formed in 1974 from the five former Wirral district councils.
A meeting of the council’s ruling “cabinet” committee this Thursday evening is being asked to approve the radical plans, which it is estimated could save the authority £3.7m a year.
To offset the closures - which the council wants to start as early as March next year - it instead intends to invest £20m over a four-year period to provide “better but fewer” buildings for taxpayers’ use.
These include five either new or improved “multi-purpose complexes” - some incorporating One Stop Shops and health centres - in Bebington, Birkenhead, Liscard, Moreton and West Kirby, and with seven other, smaller centres elsewhere in Wirral.
Both Birkenhead and Wallasey Central Libaries will be closed, but will be rehoused in the new mutli-purpose complexes to be built in their respective towns. Better opening hours, online bookings and free Wi-Fi are being mooted.
But the twelve libraries listed for complete closure are those in Hoylake, Pensby, Upton, Irby, Bromborough, Higher Bebington, New Ferry, Seacombe, Wallasey Village, Prenton, Ridgeway and Beechwood.
Woodchurch Leisure Centre, Grange Road West Sports Centre and Guinea Gap will all close, as will the Pacific Road Arts Centre, whose facilities will be transferred to the newly-refurbished Floral Pavilion in New Brighton, due to open again next month.
Council leader Steve Foulkes added: “It is essential that we carry out a comprehensive review of all the council’s built assets to ensure they are fit for the 21st Century and beyond.
“By investing £20million to provide better but fewer buildings, Wirral residents will be able to enjoy high-quality and efficient modern facilities while keeping council tax at an acceptable level.
“The residents of Wirral deserve to access excellent services from buildings that are modern and appropriate, without taxpayers having to pay for the burden of old, energy inefficient buildings that are no longer fit for purpose.
“Change is never easy and we understand that people can become attached to the buildings that they use and which are familiar to them.
“These proposals are rightly radical and comprehensive and will have implications for residents across the borough, not to mention many of our own staff.
“Through consultation and communication with all those affected, we hope to minimise any negative impact of these proposals and move towards the goal of sustainable, modern, energy efficient buildings which will also contribute to the regeneration of our poorest areas.”
The plans also include a score of buildings being transferred from being council-run to “community management” schemes.
They are community centres in Hoylake, Pensby, Kylemore, Leasowe (both Recreation and Community), Moreton, Grosvenor Ballroom, Delamere, Beechwood, Gautby Road, Livingstone Street, Noctorum, West Kirby’s Westbourne Hall, Thingwall’s Ivy Farm, New Brighton’s Vale House, New Ferry Village Hall, Heswall’s Alexander Hall and Bebington’s Victoria Hall.
The Wirral Museum - the former Birkenhead town hall in Hamilton Square - and Wirral Transport Museum, in the Pacific Road complex, are also being explored for “alternative uses” such as being taken over by trusts or even redevelopment.
Tory group leader Cllr Jeff Green said: “Before the local elections, we warned of the existence of this report. And in spite of losing seats, the Labour administration’s plans, propped up by the Liberal Democrats, have been exposed just before Christmas.
“We have to ask what the administration thinks they are there for. Providing basic public services such as libraries, leisure centres and community centres should be a priority yet these services seem to now be classed as an optional extra that Wirral no longer needs.
“If the council doesn’t do libraries, community centres or lollipop ladies, what does it do? “There will be many people who will read of these plans in disbelief - unable to understand how the council got themselves into this mess, and who can blame them?
“Labour and the Liberal Democrats have been secretive and deceitful and, as we saw with the school crossing patrols, there has been absolutely no consultation with the people who use these vital services.
“Wirral needs change. These cuts show how out of touch this council administration has become and the people of Wirral are going to pay a high price for the Labour and Liberal Democrat deal.”
The plans go before council cabinet on Thursday evening. If approved, as likely, there will then be a period of public consultation.
Comments(57)
Furor Teutonicus
says...
3:22pm Tue 25 Nov 08
As thewre was with the Newberry (sp?) by pass, or the new Heathrow terminal, the Manchester air port run way extention, or a thousand other "bright ideas" that the "Government" come up with over their morning corn flakes?
"period of public consultation." means, translated into REAL person speak;
"We will make hundreds of barristers VERY rich from enquiry after enquiry, whilst all along having NO intention of listening to the outcome, and going ahead and doing what we wanted in the first place".
nopasties
says...
6:35pm Tue 25 Nov 08
Take away the heart and watch it die.
piggymalone
says...
7:42pm Tue 25 Nov 08
glenn, moreton
says...
7:54pm Tue 25 Nov 08
MX
says...
8:37pm Tue 25 Nov 08
No it's not it's a sign that Wirral is all Foulkes'd-up......an
d I do wish he'd stop saying "doing nothing is not an option" he said that about Social Services cuts the other week (and are you surprised they have to make cuts when they have a whistleblowing bill to pay?!).
He needs to change the record and finds another catchphrase.Might I suggest "I resign...."
slowcoach90
says...
9:09pm Tue 25 Nov 08
mature student
says...
11:12pm Tue 25 Nov 08
The cuts are in the areas that really need these services, providing the ability for people with limited resources to educate themselves and meet with others for study.
I started attending Prenton library two years ago for learning to use the computer and all classes were well supported by the local people. In the last two years I have been educated to a high standard by using Prenton library. Without their help and support I would not have achieved the standard of competency I have now achieved.
My grandchild who is two years old has been registered with the Library for early learning books to progress with the most important time of his life for learning.
The Ridgeway library is where I now attend and the course is due to finish late summer 2009. Other classes are also held at Ridgeway and when I enter the library groups of people daily are in the centre discussing various projects and fundraising events.
Anne3
says...
11:23pm Tue 25 Nov 08
At a time of soaring energy costs and climate change, we need to be relocalising essential services and creating more vibrant, resilient local communities and economies. This is not the way to achieve this!
There must be an alternative.
Wirral needs a fresh voice on the council.
bigfoot
says...
12:02am Wed 26 Nov 08
TheGodSplinter
says...
5:48am Wed 26 Nov 08
You Council SCUM!
You will be remembered - name by name!
rk0001
says...
8:53am Wed 26 Nov 08
As for the ‘£11.5million’ spent by Wirral Council ‘in comprehensively redeveloping the Floral Pavilion’, £8million of this is from European funding and £1million is a private investment from Neptune Developments, with the balance which Wirral Council have contributed being repaid to them on completion of the Phase 2 development in New Brighton. So reach for your calculators and give a big hand to the Council for spending so much on our new Theatre.
Steve Foulkes (Labour) has said in this morning’s Daily Post that ‘doing nothing was never an option’ and I have to disagree with this – doing nothing may not be an option now, but the Council have got into this mess by having done nothing for many years, and their chickens are now coming home to roost. Mr Foulkes also said ‘We are a two-star authority and our aim is to become a four-star council. Sefton is larger geographically and has eight libraries, yet is a four-star council. We have 24 libraries.’ The reason Wirral is a two-star authority is the shambles of a Corporate Services department they run which dragged our rating down to two stars. This had nothing whatsoever to do with libraries and I wish Mr Foulkes well with his house-hunting in Sefton.
There are no local government elections on Wirral next year and I am sure that the Labour group think that implementing these cuts now (i.e. before the end of the current financial year) will leave enough time for the memories to fade and the broken Cultural Services department to be swept neatly under the corporate carpet in Wallasey Town Hall before elections in 2010 – out of sight, out of mind.
Steve Maddox (Chief Exec) and Jim Wilkie (his deputy) stand proudly on the deck of their sinking ship – it’s time they faced up to the fact that it was they who tore the holes in her side, and fall on their sword.
JaneS
says...
8:56am Wed 26 Nov 08
Hath
says...
10:16am Wed 26 Nov 08
re/Community Facility there. I hope that the three Conservative Councillors are going to try and opose the cuts in Wallasey but I'm not holding my breath!!! As for a central Library in Birkenhead well thats typical of funding and facilities being leeched away from Wallasey and being given to Birkenhead... What about all us Council Tax payers in Wallasey? What about the children in Wallasey who arent going to be able to travel to Birkenhead to use the Library facilities!!
Furor Teutonicus
says...
10:51am Wed 26 Nov 08
8:53am Wed 26 Nov 08
I have lived on Wirral all my life and remember clearly when growing up in the 1970’s there being one gallery (Williamson)...XXX
Obviously not THAT clearly, or you would have remembered the Lady Lever gallery as well.
Littlebabynothing
says...
10:57am Wed 26 Nov 08
We should be encouraging people to educate themselves, and free public libraries play a huge part in this.
GotTheirNumber
says...
12:38pm Wed 26 Nov 08
Doesn't feel much like that any more though, does it? Unless you can afford the fees at the Royal Liverpool, anyway - the only thing the council spends a fortune plugging, to the gain of no one but the club itself.
Kids? They're too fat, apparently. But let's take away their pools. Kids? They can't read. But who needs a book for that?
"Guy" Foulkes was quoted elsewhere saying libraries are in competition with Waterstone's. How utterly, utterly ludicrous. Fatuous, even. One is a "free" educational and cultural service. The other is a shop. Perhaps Foulkes should endeavour to find a library and look up the difference in a dictionary.
Foulkes can also be heard bleating about only being a two star council, but is oblivious that that rating has been awarded on his watched. QED, Foulkes - stand aside like the elecorate told you to, but you ignored. Not shut their libraries and close their swimming pools and scrap their museums.
Why has the council got so many in house newsletters? What does a "marketing" department actually, really, honestly do? What is it's worth? More than a library? Or a lollipop lady?
Is there really a town in China - that is that interested and knowledgeable about Wirral it hailed it as "Wirral City" - hedging its future on a tie-up with Wirral? What for? No, really - tell us. Actually tell us. No blather. No rhetoric. No droning on until we go away bored. Just tell us: What's in it for us?
The way this council is run stinks from top to bottom. It's a two star council because of its administration, not because of its citizens, and it is a disgrace that the part-time custodians of our heritage can slash away with it with one hand while wagging their podgy fingers at us with the other.
Those who can, do. Those who can't get a job in Brighton Street. Those who are even more ineffective stand in the council chamber and pretend they're in Westminister.
Welcome to the Capital of Culture Shock.
liverpoolfc88
says...
1:11pm Wed 26 Nov 08
I am a student and work part time in libraries and have spoken to many people who see the library as a place to go to chat, and elderly people who cannot manage to go to further ones. I've had people come in before who no longer live in Merseyside and say how they used to come there when they were a child.
It means that I will no longer have work and I don't understand why the council supposedly do this to 'benefit' us when all they're doing is causing trouble for people like myself.
On top of that Guinea Gap Baths is only a short walk from where I live and I have been going there for 19 years since I was a baby, so now I am also faced with the prospect that if I want to go for a 'quick' swim I have to wait for a bus to Birkenhead, then another later on when the bus I get only comes every hour of an evening!! Not only that but what about the children in Seacombe who go the swimming baths and library for something to do?, thats going to be taken away from them and so you're only going to encourage the bad behaviour, amount of ASBOS and teenage pregnancies this country struggles with.
edzbird
says...
1:47pm Wed 26 Nov 08
Bunjymurray
says...
3:35pm Wed 26 Nov 08
is. Not only are they going to close the only amenity they fund for Bromborough, no swimming pool, youth clubs etc, but they are doing it with the minimum of notification to the residents. The snivelling cowards are too frightened of the furore this decision will cause,no doubt hoping that a fait accompli will cause them the minimum of harm to themselves. There has been no consultation whatsoever. The first we hear of this proposal is the day before the council meeting in the local papers. No thought at all to the elderly, the local schools, the blood transfusion service and the local groups, all of whom use the Civic Centre. The only thing we can ensure is that the Lib Dems and Labour Councillors are never re elected. I am just one of many many disgruntled voters of Bromborough
jimbo2008
says...
4:28pm Wed 26 Nov 08
Just to point out that the Buzz Radio office in Pacific Road is the sames office only, and not the radio station.
This has not actually come from Wirral for years since the closure of hte studio nxt door to the Red Cross. This station now actually comes from Wrexham at Marcher Sound studios in Mold Road.
As for the cuts in services, this is a disgrace. It is no help to anyone living here, and certainly not to anyone living nearby the centres that are closing. If I was asked by anyone from outside the area what can Wirral offer, I would say "not a lot", if anything! What on earth are the council doing getting rid of these essential services. As far as libraries are concerned, these are important. Not everyone has access to the internet, a vital tool for today's communication revolution (or so we thought!). As for the Birkenhead Central Library, this is part of the area's heritage and should remain standing. If the council wanted to close this library, why the hell did they spend £200,000 repairing the roof last year. Don't forget - it only reopened in September!
So all in all, in real terms we lost our local radio station, we lost our lollipop ladies, we're losing our day centres aparently, we're losing the local art gallery allegedly, we're losing our libraries, and we're losing two of our swimming pools. What is left? The answer to a question what can Wirral offer - I know the answer - nothing.
Merseydiver
says...
4:39pm Wed 26 Nov 08
Bertiebadger
says...
5:43pm Wed 26 Nov 08
Is there any way a lay person can see what these people are paid, what they do and who they are?
I've seen posts advertised at ridiculous salaries in god knows what departments, responsible for god knows what?
Is it not time for a mass demonstration outside of Brighton street when a full council meeting is in session? No good us all moaning and doing nothing about it.
Time for all Councillors to resign and appoint someone competent to manage the Borough.
Don't think for a minute that the Tories would be any different either. I have had it on good authority that they wouldn't take power simply because they knew this was coming and they would rather the present incompetents took the blame.
No more council houses, no more buses, no more ferries, care homes closed, no longer responsible for providing water, cuts to lollipop services, cuts to library and leisure etc etc etc. JUST WHERE IS OUR COUNCIL TAX GOING THESE DAYS?
Hath
says...
5:56pm Wed 26 Nov 08
You can check who your local Councillors are at...
http://www.wirral.go
v.uk/members/search.
aspare by going to..
piggymalone
says...
6:29pm Wed 26 Nov 08
1. We could petition to elect a mayor
2. We could join the Residents Alliance and support their idea of only voting for independent councillors who have no party political aspirations.
Could I suggest that if anyone is interested in any of the above ideas or indeed has any good ideas of their own that they contact Glen at the Residents Alliance by e.mailing mail@residents-allia
nce.org
steady cyclist
says...
6:55pm Wed 26 Nov 08
as for saving why not recycle all the hot air council staff spout,
statictom
says...
7:02pm Wed 26 Nov 08
These cuts will be the tip of one huge iceberg. Council Transport - out to tender, Adult Day Services/Care - out to tender. Pretty soon we will not need to pay Council Tax - as there will be no services left.
Bertiebadger
says...
8:02pm Wed 26 Nov 08
I have just read part of the report and have come to realise something. A new centre in the area of Europa pools will mean more people will have to pay parking charges. If you look at the proposed other smaller centres, they are all in places difficult to park in unless you use pay and display. Who said this Council were stupid?
Well me for one because I won't use them and I am a regular at the current time.
ginger26
says...
8:17pm Wed 26 Nov 08
new brighton belle
says...
8:29pm Wed 26 Nov 08
CHANT
says...
10:52pm Wed 26 Nov 08
wirralP
says...
11:48pm Wed 26 Nov 08
AndyUpton
says...
12:25am Thu 27 Nov 08
Along with countless other people, my club (Wirral Shotokan Karate Club) has used the Woodchurch Leisure Centre for many years, and to discover this devastating news is terrible.
Where is everybody who use the Leisure Centre supposed to go ?
Elliott
says...
1:45am Thu 27 Nov 08
"Farenheit 451" by Ray Bradbury.
If the council ever gets round to destroying all of those texts, then we'll know what kind of company it would like to keep!
Dave J1608
says...
5:04am Thu 27 Nov 08
emma85
says...
8:49am Thu 27 Nov 08
I'm a member of the Panto group that uses the Woodchurch leisure centre - where are we supposed to go? It's such a fantastic place, has excellent staff and provides a real focus point for the local community! How they can even consider closing it baffles me.
It seems to me that every week the council are closing something else - Park High School, Rock Ferry school, Council workshops, Libraries and recreation centres. All the hard work people do to try and make the Wirral a better place to live is undone by the council. Yet every month we have to struggle to pay our council tax - for what I ask!!!!
I wish these people had to face the people that their decisions affect.
statictom
says...
9:54am Thu 27 Nov 08
With cuts in leasure services - just watch the rise in youth disorder in those areas effected.
glenn, moreton
says...
1:09pm Thu 27 Nov 08
If you want to know who is responsible it is your local councillor, regardless of their party, they are all complicit in the incompetent decisions which have led to this state of affairs. Instead of admitting what they've done they use deceit in order to try and deflect the blame from themselves and onto each other, or blame unelected council officers. It is the councillors who have been elected to be accountable in good times and bad. Don't let them hide from the absolute shambles they've created.
boadicea2
says...
1:31pm Thu 27 Nov 08
boadicea2
says...
1:37pm Thu 27 Nov 08
Parsopa1
says...
5:23pm Thu 27 Nov 08
Casey Jones 01
says...
10:17pm Thu 27 Nov 08
7. OFFICERS' EMOLUMENTS
The number of employees whose remuneration, excluding pension contributions, was
£50,000 or more in bands of £10,000 was:-
Remuneration Band Number of Employees
2006-07 2007-08
£50,000 - £59,999 133 161
£60,000 - £69,999 31 35
£70,000 - £79,999 20 20
£80,000 - £89,999 7 12
£90,000 - £99,999 1 4
£100,000 - £109,999 5 2
£110,000 - £119,999 1 3
£120,000 - £129,999 0 1
£130,000 - £139,999 1 1
appologys if the formatting doesn't work out right.
martin astill
says...
10:19am Fri 28 Nov 08
Dantealighieri
says...
10:46am Fri 28 Nov 08
GotTheirNumber
says...
11:23am Fri 28 Nov 08
He said another use would be found for the building.
I don't understand this. The whole point of moving out of the building is because it's too costly to repair and maintain. So how come, now Foulkes is getting some heat, it IS now capable of carrying on, just not as a library?
Does he really think we're all that stupid?
JackeyB
says...
1:49pm Fri 28 Nov 08
We have a bankrupt Council, both financially and morally. Each member of it should be ashamed of themselves, some for creating this mess, the others for standing by over the past years and doing nothing to prevent it.
They are despicable.
Christopher
says...
7:08pm Fri 28 Nov 08
raymond38
says...
7:31pm Fri 28 Nov 08
As for lib-dem hem-hangers you are a disgrace to all the wonderfull Liberals that came before you, if you can't stand on your own two feet.... fall over.
ghawkins
says...
8:05pm Fri 28 Nov 08
"Change is never easy" says Mr Foulkes... well what would they know about "change" given that they ignored the overwhelming calls for change in the May election?
It is time for Mr Foulkes to step down and Cllr Holbrook should follow.
glenn, moreton
says...
9:14pm Fri 28 Nov 08
Elliott
says...
10:31pm Fri 28 Nov 08
Mr. Foulkes, you'd better learn to make it easy, before we put you in charge of our millions, again! Look after the pennies...
librarystaff
says...
11:19pm Fri 28 Nov 08
However, although this decision has not surprised me, it has made me seriously wonder about the morals of the councillors who support these proposals.
They seem to have completely disregarded the fact that libraries play a huge part in local resident's lives. How they expect the elderly and disabled to travel halfway across Wirral to visit a library is beyond me, but it appears that they just don't care.
Most (if not all) councillors have their own transport, their own computers at home, and of course, their generous allowances to pay for such things. It's an entirely different story for many Wirral residents, how are less fortunate children supposed to access IT facilities if their local library closes? This decision will inevitably lead to children hanging around the streets as they'll have nowhere else to go, and we all know where that will lead.
Many elderly people visit their local library not just to choose books but also as a social event. They can have a cup of tea or coffee, meet friends, sit comfortably, chat and most importantly for some of the less fortunate ones, be somewhere warm and safe.
Of course, if the councillors cared about any of this they wouldn't be taking this decision anyway, so basically we're all going to Hell in a handcart!
We could ensure that these heartless councillors are voted out at the next election, but of course, they choose to do this at a time when there is NO election in sight........I can't imagine why!
Cotty-BHEAD
says...
9:58am Sat 29 Nov 08
Anyway just think,Central Library closing would be beneficial for the local dwellers of the area,it could be snapped up and a BIG gold dome put on the top whilst the council is asleep.And the money used for pay offs,or buying a bulldozer.
scouseexile
says...
9:36pm Sat 29 Nov 08
As someone whose work has taken me around many of the branches on Wirral, then I know from first hand experience just how much a part of the differnet local communities the libraries are,in many cases over several generations. Putting aside for a moment the crass and heartless manner in which staff found out about this *** before *** Christmas, what are the local communities to feel about the services on which they have come to depend being annihilated?
Do the suits who wrote this report seriously believe that an elderly person who presently can walk to a library in the daytime will take say a two bus journey in the middle of winter to a new centre where they do not know the staff or feel comfortable? Then have to wait at two stops in the cold and the rain instead of being able to walk home again in minutes? Can they believe that young mothers who take their children to reading groups or toy libraries will relish or be able to spend the extra time or money going out of their way to educate their children (and in many cases themselves too)?
The suits clearly have no idea as to the added value which branches bring to their local communities and which cannot be measured simply in financial terms.
So, if branches and leisure centres are closed, what percentage of our council tax will we get back in rebate for services which are no longer being provided?
COUNCILRIP
says...
2:42pm Sun 30 Nov 08
Future generations of people from Wallasey and Birkenhead will be left without exercise, education and entertainment.
If the Council doesn't make a U-turn on its' ridiculous cuts it is going to be WIRRAL RIP!
retriever1164
says...
10:28am Tue 2 Dec 08
•Public libraries and communities
“Public libraries are as much hubs of the community as churches, pubs and post offices”.
•Public libraries and the economy
“Public libraries help create a vibrant local economy”
Hopefully the council will rethink this heinous proposal and consider the consequences of their actions if these valuable resources are removed from the community!
Walthamster
says...
11:30am Thu 4 Dec 08
We've had a smaller version of this in Waltham Forest, where I live. But we still spend over a million pounds a year on councillors' allowances and even more on top council officers. (That's not counting all the low-paid employees and contracted-out people who do all the work.)
I once thought only Tories could destroy public services like this. But in Waltham Forest as in Wirral, it's a Labour council propped up by fawning Lib Dems.
Walthamster
says...
11:41am Thu 4 Dec 08
That means loads of money for consultants, lots of glossy documents, and heavily loaded questions to try to get the answers that suit the council. They still sometimes come up with the "wrong" answers, clearly stated by a large majority of residents. But if the results can't be massaged into what the council wants, it just ignores them and does what it had always intended.
Comment now! Register or sign in below.
Log in with us
Fields marked with * are mandatory.
Or
Log in with