News RSS Feed


Want to share your opinion, leave a tribute or comment on a news story? It's easy!

You can register for free here and comment on any of our stories.

Your news, Your views.

Cracking idea - council bans battery hen eggs

1:57pm Wednesday 16th January 2008

comment Comments (23)   Have your say »


EGGSELLENT news - Wirral is going battery hen free.

From now on, battery hen eggs will be banned from the borough's schools, care homes and canteens.

"I think the majority of people in Wirral will back us on this."

Steve Foulkes

It'll cost taxpayers £5,000 between them - but it means children and old people will be eating a "cruelty-free" food.

The move is being hailed as a victory for TV chefs Jamie Oliver and Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall, whose Big Food Fight series on Channel 4 highlighted the issue last week.

But the Globe can reveal that it is actually the result of remarkably successful campaigning by pressure group Compassion in World Farming.

Member Marian Hussenbux, from Arrowe Park, told us: "I got in touch with my local councillor John George last September, and he took the idea to council leader Steve Foulkes.

"To be honest, I wasn't sure what reaction I'd get. The CWF had just asked us to at least contact our local councils to make the point.

"As it turned out, I was pushing at an already open door. And what with the Channel 4 series airing last week, it seems synchronicity played a large part too!"

Chefs Jamie and Hugh spent last week highlighting the way chickens are treated before they arrive as meat or eggs in our shopping baskets.

Wirral council leader Steve Foulkes said: "I think the majority of people in Wirral will back us on this.

"Because of European regulations, the battery system for eggs is set to end in 2012 so we are going to pre-empt that and act now.

"In negotiating our next morning foods contract, we had already found a £25,000 saving on the previous one.

"This decision reduced that saving to £20,000, so effectively cost us £5,000."

But the TV series has not just had an effect on council thinking.

Sales of organic produce, especially chickens, have risen dramatically over the past week.

Hugh's Chicken Run and Jamie's Fowl Dinners highlighted the differences between living conditions for standard' battery chickens, enriched cages', barn, free range and organic birds.

Programme makers say that 50 years ago, chicken was a special treat that people were lucky to have once a week.

Now, thanks to modern farming methods, it has become an easily affordable everyday food, with whole birds available for just £2, even though farmers make just 3p per bird.

Tesco reported a dramatic increase in the sales of all their organic produce and completely sold out of organic chickens earlier this week.

Julie Davies, duty manager at Tesco in Bidston, said: "The store has been selling unusually large amounts of organic and free-range produce and we'll now be increasing our supply of organic produce to meet the demands of the customer."

Simon Bunyan, manager at Sainsbury's in Prenton, says they have also witnessed a leap in the sales of organic chickens.

"We've definitely seen an uplift in organic chicken sales as well as the taste-the-difference free range products as well," he said.

"It's clear that it is a direct result of these tv programmes last week, as we wouldn't normally see a rise in these sales at this time of the year."

Telly chef Hugh said he plans to kickstart a chicken revolution by replacing cheap chickens sold by supermarkets for ethically reared free-range chicken.

Did you know?

Chicken is Britain's most popular meat

We eat 12 times as much chicken as we did 30 years ago. Our demand means that not only is it mass-produced, it is also dirt cheap

855 million chickens are produced in the UK every year

Some supermarkets are selling whole birds for as little as £2

Chickens are cheaper than some dog food. But this low cost is not necessarily good for the farmer or the birds.

Every day 100,000 birds die in standard chicken farms due to poor welfare conditions


Your Say YourWirral Globe

Spiffy, wallasey says...
3:08pm Wed 16 Jan 08

Umm.

"In negotiating our next morning foods contract, we had already found a £25,000 saving on the previous one."

Alrighty then, so the council £25,000. Cool.

"This decision reduced that saving to £20,000, so effectively cost us £5,000."

..........

Um no, it still saved the council £5,000. O and it saved the taxpayers £5,000.

I despair, honestly....


Spiffy, wallasey says...
3:10pm Wed 16 Jan 08

...and I also miss words out...

That should have read

"Alrighty then, so the council SAVED £25,000. Cool."

Just going to go off and despair of myself now :))

Chris Bindall, Wirral says...
4:07pm Wed 16 Jan 08

Um, no Spiffy - if the original "saving" of £25,000 was reduced to £20,000, then the decision has indeed "cost" the council £5,000.

They did, howevber, save £20,000 overall though!

teki, Birkenhead says...
4:55pm Wed 16 Jan 08

Good. It's a start. It's probably due to all this factory farming we have all these diseases. And just because their going to die there's no need to be cruel to them.

Andy, Wirral says...
5:28pm Wed 16 Jan 08

I think it is a "cracking" idea which has been waiting to "hatch" for a long time.

Rob Roy, wirral says...
6:51pm Wed 16 Jan 08

Is that supposed to be a yolk. It cracked me up that did. I don't care wot eggs or chickens i eat. At the end of the day they are not bred for pets. They all end up dead and eaten. If you all care that much about chickens. Then don't eat them at all.

teki, Birkenhead says...
8:50pm Wed 16 Jan 08

I don't care for you much and I wouldn't eat you. If a chicken is going to fill my belly I could show it a little respect while it's alive.

Spiffy, wallasey says...
10:22pm Wed 16 Jan 08

Um Chris...I bow to your superior theoretical maths skills. You are correct to highlight that they saved £20,000 over all.

The spin is probably so taxpayers wont be able to work that out at first glance. I dont pay tax so I wouldnt really count as a victory there.

Hmm....In negotiating they hadnt actually spent or lost anything at all - yet. You cant actually save or lose what you havent actually spent yet.

I do hope my council tax is going down as a result of savings though. :)

Dave Rimmer, Wallasey says...
10:27pm Wed 16 Jan 08

855 million chickens produced each year eh. What would the environmental impact of that lot roaming the country free range. For the mathematicians that equates to 9193 chickens for every square mile of Britain. Totally agree with Rob Roy, if your that concerned, don't eat chicken or their eggs.

Bernard Mc mathews, Free rangepulp farming factory? says...
11:17pm Wed 16 Jan 08

KLUKIN ELL!!!! you council people...You make me laugh!...Theres a ban waggon lets jump on it!PROVE THE SUPER DOOPER MARKETS only sell comfy chickens!!!!! before they get killed...You people would sell your grandads plot for car parkin space!NO? well you would'nt think twice before you sold mine!Why dont you all buy hemp suits? and wear flip flops?Someone pulls the strings and you lot dance!

Kathleen, says...
9:45am Thu 17 Jan 08

Like all sentient creatures, chickens should have the opportunity to live in conditions that allow them to exercise their natural behaviours, such laying their eggs in a nest, foraging, perching, and even doing simple things like walking and spreading their wings, none of which they can do in a barren wire cage. Battery eggs are cheaper, but it is hens that pay the price, with lives filled with pain, stress and frustration. Congratulations to Wirral Council and all those involved for this enlightened, compassionate decision.

Helen Faulkes, West Midlands says...
10:02am Thu 17 Jan 08

I wish all councils would follow in this admirable decision.Cruelty is cruelty,and I for one abhor 'intensive farming',as do many others.

teki, Birkenhead says...
12:07pm Thu 17 Jan 08

Who said it was everyones "right" to eat chickens? Why can't they live like sheep and make them more expensive,if you can't afford one,tough.

Mr Bollo, says...
12:14pm Thu 17 Jan 08

A good idea - un oeuf said I think...

Colonal Sanders, Kentucky says...
4:08pm Thu 17 Jan 08

I think it's an excellent idea to eat chickens.

If we didn't, they take over the earth.

And what's wrong with battery hens? Surely we need new sources of energy?

Robin, Chester says...
11:12pm Thu 17 Jan 08

What happens after 2012? Will the Council ban eggs from the newly developed colony (enriched cage)system as well? They are a world apart from the terrible old battery cages as shown in the studio on Jamie's programme.Hens can run,flap,scratch and lay eggs in nest boxes in clean disease free conditions safe from wild birds carrying bird flu and storms and floods.We need to produce eggs from free range, barn and colony systems after 2012 in order to replace lost battery egg production in the UK otherwise eggs will be in short supply and become very expensive, costing the taxpayer more than the £5000 as quoted in your report.

dave, bebington says...
10:03am Fri 18 Jan 08

Classic!

seeing as the basic food stuff and energy prices are going skyhigh how can pensions and others on low income afford this cowboy food prices let alone afford the energy prices to cook their food!!

Well Done Nanny State for bringing back Death by Poverty

Duncan, Lymm says...
10:58am Fri 18 Jan 08

We need to produce eggs that everyone can afford.....otherwise the supermarkets will import them from abroad where the word welfare does not exist.

Nemo, says...
11:23am Fri 18 Jan 08

Duncan wrote:
We need to produce eggs that everyone can afford.....otherwise the supermarkets will import them from abroad where the word welfare does not exist.
Quite. But local and national government will not care about this, even supposing that they have thought about it. They can 'tick the box' for being kind to domestic chickens, pat themselves on the back again for a 'job well done' and quietly ignore what happens in other countries. Oh, and of course, the extra cost of domestic free-range eggs won't bother them as they can just vote themselves and above-inflation pay rise.

Guy, Wirral says...
4:36pm Sat 19 Jan 08

Robin, Ducan & Nemo present a well balanced synopsis of the facts, not an emotive rant, or biased reporting as portrayed by the TV chefs & others. Free Range hens/eggs are fine but will always cost more to produce. Whilst enriched cages provide a sensible alternative to producing affordable food in the UK rather than importing from countries where we have no control over hygiene & welfare conditions - let alone the obvious environmental issues from transporting the goods. The choice should be down to the consumer not enforced by any authority. Why not start a campaign to prohibit all poultry/egg imports ... particularly those who say they are so concerned about the rights of hens to roam?!

Tate, b-head says...
1:39pm Sun 20 Jan 08

Just had a battery hen. Never again. had to spit the duracell out.

Peter, Cheshire, Cage farmer says...
12:11pm Wed 30 Jan 08

Do you know the truth. I challenge any of you do gooders to go and find out the truth about free range, they suffer more stress than cage hens (proved by a recent study that showed more stress hormone in free range rather than cage eggs). If a chicken is not happy in any way the first thing it does is stop laying eggs. We have the same breed of hens in both systems how come our cage chcikens lay more eggs. Chickens form cage eggs are just as happy as free range production figures prove it. They are not like you and me all they want is a safe warm environment with a good supply of food and water. You lot go and see your nearest free range farm now. knee deep in mud and not a chicken outside the house just up 16,000 birds in one big cage(a shed) dont kill the UK battery farm i have traveled the world looking at cage egg production and you dont want the cheap imports!!!!!!!!!!!!
Plase reply i would be intrested.

Rebecca, Bath says...
11:43am Thu 28 Feb 08

You have got a point. The regulations are that a chicken must have atleast 1 square meter of space to make it legally 'free range'. That isn't much at all, not to mention that these conditions only must apply for "have had during at least half lifetime "- DEFRA
'Free Range - Total Freedom' seems to be the best way forward, complete open access. I believe that it is right to give the chickens a right to a happy life, and not treat them as a bit of meat on two legs that costs £1.99, nor what they produce. Go here to see what Diestel Turkey Ranch in Northern California do to their turkeys: http://www.free-rang

e-turkey.com/wst_pag

e2.php

Comments are closed on this article.

Local advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »